Fishing reviews and guest experiences

“Bill gave our two boys the best introduction to fly fishing possible on the River Tweed. His infinite patience made sure the boys got the maximum from the session. Highly recommended.”

“My daughter, husband and I came from the USA to fish the Tweed with Al and Fergie. The waders, boots, rods and flies were excellent. We waded a small section and each caught fish—three different species. I learned Euro-nymphing!”

“We loved our experience. Fergie was a great guide: helpful, knowledgeable and patient with my two boys. He put us on fish when even the locals weren’t catching. I highly recommend booking your experience with these guys—you’ll have a blast.”

“My 15-year-old son and I booked a day trip on the Tweed. James was terrific and very patient with both of us. Highly recommend.”

“Had a great day with Rob! He was a very professional guide and a great person to spend a day on the water with. I will definitely be coming back to fish with him again.”

“I had a great day fishing with guide Stephen. We caught rainbow trout at a spot near St Andrews. Thanks Bill for setting it up.”

“Unbelievable experience fishing in Scotland. It was everything I wanted, and a spring salmon more. Bill was great with communicating and getting us booked and teamed with one of the best guides I’ve ever used, Stephen. I’ll remember that trip for the rest of my life.”

“A most wonderful experience! My guide was extremely knowledgeable and a great teacher for a novice fly fisher like me. Both the Best Fishing Scotland team and my guide were extraordinarily wonderful. I strongly recommend them.”

“The scenery was breathtaking and you were an outstanding coach. You moved between beginners and experienced family members with ease, helping each of us in ways tailored to our abilities. Your stories of the river’s history and traditions made the day one of our family highlights.”

“A brilliant day on the Tweed! Low water and a cool breeze were not promising, but I was shown new ways of nymph fishing and provided with superb equipment. I learned so much, it was fun—and I caught fish. A day to remember and definitely worth five stars!”

“Neither of us had fly-fished before, and Bill was more than helpful in teaching us what we needed. He took us to a beautiful, secluded spot, shared local facts and kept us entertained throughout the day. It was even more enjoyable than anticipated and an experience we will remember.”

“Everything was great! We had a blast and everyone caught something. The guides were superb; everyone could cast even a salmon rod after a few tries and instructions. Thank you for arranging everything. We hope to come back someday.”

“We had a fabulous day and James was an excellent guide and lovely guy. We both had a school day in fantastic surroundings and enjoyed Borders hospitality that evening feeling we’d had a great day. We’re both eager to get back into river fishing.”

“Many thanks for taking Stephen and me fishing. The trip was epic, from the flora and fauna to your gracious hospitality. We both had a splendid time. Your guiding prowess is over the top as well—you are the bomb!”

“My friend and I had two amazing days with Bill and James on the Till at Tiptoe Farm. Their knowledge of the river, fish and insect life was impressive and resulted in good trout and grayling in the net. Friendly, professional guides in a truly beautiful environment.”

“The Euro-nymphing technique was new to me and, thanks to your very competent teaching, I saw how effective it can be. Carol and I connected immediately with your guiding style. Thank you also for your patience in getting us started in Spey casting. We both had a splendid time.”

“Together with five old friends I spent a few great days fly fishing on the beautiful River Tweed. Bill and Roger taught us fly fishing from A–Z with patience and professional tips. We also learned about Scotland’s nature, history, country and people. It made our holiday unforgettable.”

“Bill is a fantastic guide with immense knowledge of the local area and the art of Euro-nymphing. He has a great sense of humour and will tell you many a story. We had the water to ourselves and the day went by so fast. I highly recommend a day fishing with Bill.”